Comments on Choice­Mail One

Choice­Mail One, by Digi­Portal Soft­ware Inc., is one of the most sensitive spam filters I know. It runs on your Windows work­station, sitting between your ISP's email servers and your own mail client, much like a tiny proxy server. Choice­Mail fetches your incoming email from your provider's server and processes it so that your normal email program will see your non-spam messages only.

Choice­Mail basics

White­lists

The fundamental logic Choice­Mail follows is that incoming mail is spam unless specifically welcomed. (This principle of initial denial is more commonly applied to fire­wall and router configuration. Allowing only necessary traffic is usually safer than fixing leaks on a whack-a-mole basis.) In practice, Choice­Mail will accept messages "from" white­listed email addresses. You should generate an initial white­list from your email address book. Choice­Mail will also pre-emptively white­list every address to which you send mail. Additionally, you can have Choice­Mail apply rules you write yourself.

Challenges and responses

However, what if you want to get rid of spam while receiving mail from persons you have not white­listed yet? When you get mail from an unknown address, Choice­Mail can automatically send a confirmation request (a challenge) to the ostensible sender, asking him or her to complete a short form on a web page. If they do, you will be notified, and, based on the reason they have provided, have the option to allow or deny their mail. On the other hand, if the sender is a spammer, they are unlikely to respond, and Choice­Mail will automatically purge the original message after a few days.

Not a perfect solution

There are a few caveats of which you should be aware:

Do not become part of the spam problem

Opponents have voiced the opinion that any challenges Choice­Mail may send would constitute spam.

Automatic responses are widely used. Inter­net standards even require auto-responses to be sent in various situations. Nevertheless, it is important to remember that email addresses are easy to falsify. Make every effort to avoid challenging unrelated third parties.

Choice­Mail makes the following checks before deciding to send a challenge:

These rules are power­ful. Use them as extensively as possible, falling back on the challenge-response feature only if none of them matches. Also note that you can disable challenges altogether; if you do, you will instead need to review the list of unknown senders manually.

Need support? Jump through hoops

You cannot expect to email Digi­Portal's Choice­Mail support and receive an emailed response.

Google’s use of the DART cookie enables Google to serve ads to you based on your visits to this and other websites. If you do not wish to use the DART cookie, please opt out on the privacy policy page for Google’s ad-and-content network. Additionally, you can usually specify your cookie preferences in your browser settings.

All content © 2000–2012 Thor Kottelin t/a Turvasana Tmi, unless otherwise indicated. Any trademarks or registered trademarks mentioned on this site belong to their respective owners. Content and techniques used on this site may be available for licensing; for details, please contact the webmaster. — Conventional hyperlinking to this site is welcome. However, none of the content on this site may be shown, even partly, in a context inferring or claiming it to be part of or sponsored by any other organisation or site. Such prohibited techniques include (but are not limited to) framesets, interstitial pages, kiosk mode pop-ups and reverse proxies. — For information on advertising, please click on the ‘Ads by Google’ or ‘AdChoices’ link next to any advertisement.

38.107.179.214 (none)
(none) CCBot/1.0 (+http://www.commoncrawl.org/bot.html)
/irt/choicemail.shtml /irt/choicemail.shtml Saturday, 11-Feb-2012 16:46:08 EET